Sweet potato and pumpkin are two of the most popular dog-friendly ingredients — both gentle, nutritious, and loved by dogs of all ages. But when it comes to treats, digestion, and everyday use, one may suit your dog better depending on their needs.
This guide breaks down the differences so you can choose the best option for your dog.
Is Pumpkin Better Than Sweet Potatoes for Dogs?
Pumpkin and sweet potato are both excellent for dogs, but they shine in different ways.
Pumpkin is lower in calories, higher in water content, and great for dogs needing digestive support.
Sweet potato is richer, more filling, slightly sweeter, and offers more energy and fiber.
For dogs who enjoy sweet, chewy treats, sweet potato tends to win. Many natural treats — like Sweet Potato Slices or Sweet Potato Fries — provide that classic chewy texture dogs love while staying gentle on digestion.
Pumpkin, however, is easier to mix into soft treats or freeze, which is why many homemade treat blogs use pumpkin for “soft bake” recipes.
Is Pumpkin Better Than Sweet Potatoes Overall?
Neither is universally “better” — they simply support different needs.
Choose pumpkin if your dog:
-
needs mild digestive help
-
is on a weight-management plan
-
prefers soft-textured treats
-
needs lower-calorie options
Choose sweet potato if your dog:
-
prefers chewy or crispy treats
-
needs more fiber or fullness
-
enjoys long-lasting natural snacks
-
has a sensitive stomach and needs predictable ingredients
Many dog nutrition blogs (like K9 of Mine) compare the two and consistently note that pumpkin supports digestion, while sweet potato supports energy, satiety, and chewing satisfaction.
What Is the Healthiest Vegetable for Dogs?
There isn’t one “healthiest” vegetable — different veggies support different needs. But the most commonly recommended include:
-
Sweet potato
-
Pumpkin
-
Carrots
-
Green beans
Among these, sweet potato is one of the most nutrient-dense, especially for treats. Natural chews like Sweet Potato Slices or Sweet Potato Sticks offer vitamins, fiber, and a satisfying chew without added ingredients.
Pumpkin, on the other hand, is lighter, more hydrating, and perfect for soft treats or mix-ins.
Is Pumpkin or Sweet Potato Better for Dogs With an Upset Stomach?
Pumpkin is usually the better choice for acute stomach upset because:
-
It's high in soluble fiber
-
It helps firm stool
-
It’s gentle on sensitive bellies
This is why many vets and pet health articles recommend a spoonful of pumpkin during mild digestive episodes.
Sweet potato is also stomach-friendly — especially air-dried options like Sweet Potato Slices — but pumpkin tends to work faster for temporary stomach issues.
For dogs with chronic sensitivity, sweet potato may actually be more predictable because it’s a single-ingredient chew that digests slowly and steadily. Many owners of sensitive dogs prefer sweet potato-based treats for this reason.
Pumpkin Treats vs Sweet Potato Treats: When to Use Each
Pumpkin treats are best for:
-
Senior dogs need softer textures
-
Dogs needing digestive support
-
Hot-weather frozen treats
-
Picky eaters who prefer mild flavors
Sweet potato treats are best for:
-
Chewers who prefer a firmer, chewy texture
-
Dogs needing a filling, slow-digesting snack
-
Sensitive dogs require ingredient simplicity
-
Owners who want natural, long-lasting chews like Sweet Potato Slices or Sweet Potato Fries
Final Thoughts
Pumpkin and sweet potato are both excellent for dogs — just in different ways. Pumpkin is the gentle, soft, digestive-friendly option. Sweet potato is the chewy, nutrient-rich, satisfying treat that works for almost every dog and every sensitivity level.
If your dog loves to chew or needs a clean, natural snack, sweet potato treats like Sweet Potato Slices, Sweet Potato Fries, or Sweet Potato Sticks are a reliable everyday choice.
For digestive support or soft baking, pumpkin is hard to beat.