Pig Ears vs. Cow Ears for Dogs: Which Natural Chew Lasts Longer and Stays Safer?

Posted by Brutus & Barnaby on

BRUTUS & BARNABY

Pig Ears vs. Cow Ears for Dogs: Which Natural Chew Lasts Longer and Stays Safer?

Natural treats for dogs — quality you can trust.

TL;DR — Key Takeaways
  • Pig ears are softer, fattier, and perfect for smaller or senior dogs who need a gentler chew.
  • Cow ears are leaner, longer-lasting, and a great fit for medium to large dogs who love a satisfying challenge.
  • Both are single-ingredient, natural chews with no artificial additives when sourced responsibly.
  • Digestibility matters more than durability — always match the chew to your dog's size and chewing style.
  • Brutus and Barnaby pig ears and cow ears are all-natural, minimally processed, and made with your dog's wellbeing in mind.

Did you know that the natural chew market for dogs has grown by over 30% in the last five years — and pig ears and cow ears are two of the top reasons why? More dog moms are ditching mystery ingredient rawhide in favor of single-ingredient chews they can actually feel good about handing over. But when it comes to pig ears vs cow ears for dogs, a lot of people aren't sure which one is the right fit. Let's walk through it together.


✗
Artificial smoke flavoring
Sodium nitrite (preservative)
Bleaching agents (hydrogen peroxide or chlorine-based)
Added salt
Propylene glycol (moisture retainer)
Artificial colorings
Chemical tanning byproducts

Warning: Many budget pig ear and cow ear brands use chemical processing to improve shelf appearance and extend life. These additives have no place  in your dog's chew routine and are a key reason why sourcing matters so much.
✓
100% natural pork ear (pig ears)

100% natural beef ear (cow ears)

That is the complete list.

No artificial preservatives. No bleaching agents. No added flavors. Air-dried and naturally preserved. Just the real thing, exactly as nature made it.
Fat Content ✓ Cow ears are naturally low in fat, making them a smarter choice for dogs watching their weight. ✗ Pig ears are higher in fat — still fine in moderation, but not ideal for every dog.
Chew Duration ✓ Cow ears last longer — great for strong chewers who need more engagement time. ✗ Pig ears tend to go faster, especially for medium and large breeds.
Softness and Texture ✓ Pig ears are softer and more flexible — ideal for puppies, seniors, or gentle chewers. ✗ Cow ears are tougher, which may not suit older dogs with dental sensitivities.
Digestibility ✓ Both digest far better than rawhide; cow ears are slightly gentler on sensitive stomachs. ✗ Pig ears are richer and may cause loose stools if introduced too quickly.
Protein Content ✓ Cow ears offer a leaner protein profile, supporting muscle without extra calories. ✗ Pig ears have a higher fat-to-protein ratio, which affects caloric density.
Ingredient Simplicity ✓ Brutus & Barnaby offers both as single-ingredient, naturally dried chews with zero additives. ✗ Many brands add smoke flavoring, preservatives, or bleaching agents to both ear types.
Size Suitability ✓ Cow ears work well for medium to large dogs; pig ears are a perfect size for small breeds too. ✗ Generic brands rarely size or label their chews clearly, making it harder to match to your dog.


When you're comparing pig ears vs cow ears for dogs, the first thing worth looking at is what they're actually made of. Pig ears are cartilage and skin, which means they have a softer, more pliable texture and a naturally higher fat content. For most healthy adult dogs, that fat is not a problem in moderation — but if your pup is on a weight management plan or has a sensitive stomach, it's something to keep in mind. Cow ears, on the other hand, are predominantly skin with very little cartilage, making them noticeably leaner and lower in fat. That difference in composition is really what drives everything else — the texture, the chew time, and how your dog's body handles them afterward. Digestibility is one of the most important factors when choosing any chew, and both pig and cow ears do well here compared to rawhide, which is one of the main reasons so many dog owners have made the switch. Both are made from animal byproducts that dogs have been eating for centuries, and when they're minimally processed — dried rather than chemically treated — they break down in a way that's much gentler on the digestive system. Cow ears tend to be slightly easier to digest for dogs with sensitive stomachs because of their lower fat content. Pig ears, while still very digestible, are richer, so a dog who isn't used to them might need a slow introduction. You can explore all of our Pig & Cow Ears options to see what might be the right starting point for your dog. Safety in natural chews really comes down to how they're processed and where they come from. Chews that are bleached, chemically treated, or loaded with preservatives introduce risks that have nothing to do with the ingredient itself. That's why at Brutus & Barnaby, we keep things simple — minimal processing, no artificial additives, no shortcuts. Whether you're looking at our PIG EARS TREATS or our COW EARS TREATS, you're getting a chew that starts and ends with one real ingredient. That's the standard we hold ourselves to, because we know you're trusting us with someone you love.




Frequently Asked Questions

QAre pig ears or cow ears safer for dogs?
Both can be very safe when they come from a trusted source and are minimally processed. The biggest risk with any chew isn't the ingredient — it's the processing. Chews that are chemically treated or bleached are the ones to avoid. Brutus & Barnaby PIG EARS and COW EARS are naturally dried with no artificial additives, which is what makes them a choice you can feel good about.
QWhich lasts longer — a pig ear or a cow ear?
Cow ears generally last longer than pig ears because they are denser and tougher in texture. For a dog who loves to chew and you want them occupied for a good stretch of time, cow ears tend to win that race. Pig ears are softer and get worked through more quickly, which can actually be a better fit for smaller dogs or seniors who shouldn't be chewing hard for long periods.
QCan small dogs have pig ears and cow ears?
Yes, small dogs can enjoy both, though pig ears are often a better starting point for smaller breeds because of their softer texture and manageable size. Always supervise your dog with any chew, regardless of size. If your small dog is a determined chewer who tends to gulp pieces rather than chew them thoroughly, opt for something sized appropriately and always take the chew away once it gets small enough to swallow whole.
QAre cow ears good for dogs with sensitive stomachs?
Cow ears are actually one of the more stomach-friendly chew options available. They are low in fat and made from a single animal protein, which means there is less in them to upset a sensitive digestive system. When comparing pig ears vs cow ears for dogs with tummy sensitivities, cow ears are usually the gentler choice. That said, always introduce any new chew slowly and watch how your dog responds the first couple of times.
QHow often should I give my dog a pig ear or cow ear?
Most vets suggest treating natural chews as an occasional reward rather than a daily staple — a few times a week is a reasonable starting point for most dogs. Because pig ears are higher in fat, you may want to limit those to once or twice a week, especially for dogs prone to weight gain or pancreatitis. Cow ears can be offered a little more freely given their lower fat content, but as always, balance is everything.

Shop Brutus & Barnaby

Browse our full range of natural dog treats.

Shop Now
Important Notice
Disclaimer: The information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute veterinary advice. Always consult your veterinarian before making changes to your pet's diet, health routine, or treat selection, especially if your dog has existing health conditions, allergies, or is on medication. Individual results may vary. Brutus & Barnaby products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or medical condition. Statements regarding product benefits have not been evaluated by the FDA unless specified. Ingredient sourcing and product formulations are subject to change — always refer to current product packaging for the most accurate information. Keep all treats out of reach of children. Supervise your dog when offering any chew or treat.
← Older Post Newer Post →